CONTACT US TODAY AT 212-605-0343
How To Qualify for Disability Benefits With Fibromyalgia

Is Fibromyalgia a Disability? Qualifying for SSDI Benefits

 

Fibromyalgia may qualify for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits, but the path to approval differs from most other disabling conditions. Fibromyalgia has no dedicated listing in the SSA’s Blue Book. Instead, it is evaluated under Social Security Ruling 12-2p, and approval depends on whether your medical record documents that the condition prevents you from engaging in any substantial gainful activity.

 

Some people with fibromyalgia manage their symptoms well enough to remain employed. Others live with widespread pain, severe fatigue, and cognitive difficulties that make sustained work impossible. For individuals who are unable to work, SSR 12-2p provides two diagnostic pathways for establishing fibromyalgia as a medically determinable impairment: the 1990 ACR tender-point criteria and the 2010 ACR symptom-based criteria. From there, the RFC evaluation is where most approved claims are won, and working with a Social Security disability lawyer improves your chances of approval at this stage.

 

Key Takeaways

  • Fibromyalgia has no dedicated Blue Book listing. It is evaluated entirely under Social Security Ruling 12-2p.
  • SSR 12-2p provides two diagnostic paths: the 1990 ACR tender-point criteria requiring 11 of 18 positive points, and the 2010 ACR symptom-based criteria requiring 6 or more documented symptoms.
  • Only a licensed physician can establish fibromyalgia as a medically determinable impairment. Nurse practitioners and physician assistants cannot make the diagnosis.
  • Most fibromyalgia claims are won through the RFC evaluation, not by medically equaling a listing.

 

What Is Fibromyalgia?

Fibromyalgia is a chronic pain condition characterized primarily by widespread musculoskeletal pain, fatigue, sleep disturbance, and cognitive difficulties that has persisted for at least three months. Unlike conditions such as arthritis or a herniated disc, fibromyalgia produces no visible tissue damage. There is no abnormality on imaging and no laboratory marker that confirms the diagnosis.

 

The condition frequently co-occurs with depression, anxiety, irritable bowel syndrome, migraines, and temporomandibular joint disorders. SSR 12-2p explicitly identifies co-occurring conditions as relevant factors in the disability evaluation, and they can compound the functional limitations fibromyalgia produces on its own.

 

Because no blood test or imaging study can conclusively confirm fibromyalgia, the SSA issued SSR 12-2p to establish exactly what evidence it requires and cannot require from claimants.

 

Symptoms of Fibromyalgia That Matter for a Social Security Disability Claim

Not all fibromyalgia symptoms carry equal weight in a disability evaluation. The SSA is interested in symptoms that prevent you from performing sustained work activity on a regular and continuing basis.

 

A woman struggling with fibromyalgia symptoms sits on a couch as she leans over and places a hand on her head.Symptoms that are most relevant to a disability claim include:

  • Widespread pain: Pain in all four quadrants of the body—both sides, above and below the waist—that persists for at least three months. The pain may fluctuate in intensity, which is precisely why the SSA requires longitudinal records rather than a snapshot from a single examination.
  • Fatigue and reduced stamina: Exhaustion that prevents you from maintaining a consistent schedule or completing a full workday. This is distinct from ordinary tiredness and must be documented in your treating physician’s notes.
  • Cognitive impairment (fibro fog): Difficulty concentrating, remembering instructions, and maintaining a consistent pace. This affects the ability to perform sedentary work that requires sustained mental focus.
  • Sleep disturbance: Waking unrefreshed despite adequate time in bed, which compounds both pain and fatigue and reduces functional capacity throughout the day.
  • Co-occurring conditions: Depression, anxiety, irritable bowel syndrome, and other conditions that frequently accompany fibromyalgia and further limit your ability to sustain work.

 

Because fibromyalgia symptoms fluctuate, a single medical appointment that shows relative improvement does not accurately represent your functional capacity. The SSA specifically accounts for this variability and requires longitudinal treatment records rather than a one-time evaluation. An experienced SSDI attorney can help ensure your longitudinal record is complete and presents your limitations accurately before you file your initial SSDI claim.

 

SSR 12-2p—The Social Security Ruling That Governs Fibromyalgia Claims

Fibromyalgia is not in the SSA’s Blue Book. Because no listing exists for it, fibromyalgia cannot satisfy a Blue Book listing at Step 3 of the SSDI benefits evaluation. Instead, the SSA evaluates all fibromyalgia disability claims under Social Security Ruling 12-2p.

 

SSR 12-2p establishes the framework for proving that fibromyalgia is a medically determinable impairment (MDI). Only a licensed physician can establish an MDI of fibromyalgia. A nurse practitioner or physician assistant cannot. The evidence must document that the physician reviewed your medical history and conducted a physical examination. A diagnosis statement alone is not sufficient under the ruling.

 

The ruling provides two diagnostic paths. Either can establish fibromyalgia as an MDI, and the SSA will use whichever path the available evidence best supports.

 

Path A — 1990 ACR Criteria

All three of the following must be present:

  1. Widespread pain. A history of pain in all four quadrants of the body—both sides, above and below the waist—and axial skeletal pain in the cervical spine, anterior chest, thoracic spine, or low back. This pain must have persisted for at least three months. It may fluctuate in intensity and may not always be present.
  2. At least 11 of 18 positive tender points on physical examination. The 18 tender-point sites are located at the occiput, low cervical spine, trapezius, supraspinatus, second rib, lateral epicondyle, gluteal, greater trochanter, and inner aspect of the knee. Testing is performed by digital palpation with approximately 9 pounds of pressure. A point is positive if you experience any pain when that pressure is applied. The positive points must be found bilaterally and both above and below the waist.
  3. Evidence that other disorders were ruled out. Other medical conditions can produce the same or similar symptoms as fibromyalgia, including rheumatologic disorders, myofascial pain syndrome, polymyalgia rheumatica, chronic Lyme disease, and cervical hyperextension disorders. Laboratory testing to rule these out may include a complete blood count, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, antinuclear antibody, thyroid function, and rheumatoid factor.

 

Path B — 2010 ACR Preliminary Diagnostic Criteria

All three of the following must be present:

  1. Widespread pain. Same as criterion 1 under Path A.
  2. Six or more fibromyalgia symptoms, signs, or co-occurring conditions. Repeated manifestations of at least six symptoms, especially fatigue, cognitive or memory problems, waking unrefreshed, depression, anxiety disorder, or irritable bowel syndrome. SSR 12-2p’s full list includes muscle pain, headache, abdominal pain, numbness or tingling, dizziness, insomnia, and others.
  3. Evidence that other disorders were ruled out. Same as criterion 3 under Path A.

Path B is available when tender-point testing results are not in your medical record. SSR 12-2p states explicitly that the SSA may use the 2010 criteria when the case record does not include tender-point testing results, or when the report does not describe the number and location of positive tender points.

 

How Many Fibromyalgia Claimants Receive SSDI Benefits: The RFC Pathway

Because no Blue Book listing exists for fibromyalgia, the sequential evaluation never reaches a finding of disability at Step 3 for most claimants. Fibromyalgia can only medically equal a listing; SSR 12-2p specifically gives inflammatory arthritis listing 14.09D as an example, or medically equal a listing in combination with another medically determinable impairment. Most fibromyalgia claims that succeed do so at Steps 4 and 5 through the Residual Functional Capacity (RFC) evaluation.

 

The RFC documents what you can still do physically and mentally despite your fibromyalgia. The SSA then uses your RFC alongside your age, education, and work history to determine whether any work exists in the national economy that you can realistically perform on a sustained, full-time basis.

 

For claimants over 50, the Medical-Vocational Guidelines, commonly called the Grid Rules, give significant weight to age when evaluating whether you can realistically transition to different work while managing fibromyalgia. A claimant over 50 who cannot return to past work and whose RFC is limited to sedentary activity faces a meaningfully different evaluation than a younger claimant with the same limitations.

 

A Social Security disability lawyer can ensure your RFC limitations are presented effectively in your claim and increase your chances of receiving benefits.

 

What Medical Evidence Strengthens a Fibromyalgia SSDI Claim

Your claim should include:

  • A fibromyalgia SSDI lawyer talks with a client about how they can qualify for social security disability benefits. Longitudinal physician treatment notes. Records from your treating physician spanning a significant period, documenting physical examination findings, tender-point testing or symptom assessments, treatment history, and your physician’s assessment of your functional abilities over time. The SSA places particular weight on longitudinal records precisely because fibromyalgia symptoms fluctuate.
  • Rheumatologist documentation. Evaluation and treatment records from a rheumatologist carry significant weight with SSA decision-makers.
  • Lab work ruling out other conditions. Records of testing that excluded other disorders satisfy the third criterion under both SSR 12-2p diagnostic paths and reinforce the legitimacy of the fibromyalgia diagnosis.
  • An RFC assessment from your treating physician. A form completed by your physician documenting your specific work-related limitations, such as how long you can sit, stand, and walk, how much you can lift, how often you would be off-task, and how many days per month you would likely miss work, carries significant weight at every stage of the evaluation.
  • Third-party statements. SSR 12-2p explicitly identifies statements from neighbors, friends, relatives, former employers, and others as relevant evidence for evaluating the severity and functional effects of fibromyalgia. These statements can document how your daily functioning compares to what medical records alone capture.

 

If you have any gaps in medical treatment, questions may arise about your symptom’s severity and may weaken a claim at both the initial and hearing levels.

 

How A Social Security Disability Lawyer Can Help

Fibromyalgia claims require building a longitudinal medical record that documents how your symptoms accumulate and fluctuate over time—a different challenge from conditions where imaging tells most of the story. Many initial claims are denied not because the applicant does not qualify, but because the medical record does not yet establish the severity and consistency of functional limitations the SSA requires. A Social Security disability lawyer can identify those gaps before you submit your initial applications and help you build the right record before you file.

 

If your application is denied, you have the right to appeal through reconsideration, a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge, the SSA Appeals Council, and federal court. Representation at the hearing stage can strengthen your claim.

Bender and Bender Lawyers outside courthouse.

"*" indicates required fields

Bender and Bender bookshelf about social security disability claim process.

Need help with your claim?

A patient talks to their doctor about qualifying for social security disability benefits.

Wondering what other conditions may qualify for benefits?

Paperwork needing a social security disability appeal.

Was your initial claim denied?

Social Security Frequently Asked Questions Blocks

Do you have more questions about Social Security Disability?

Social Security Benefits Calculator calculating clients benefits.

Wondering how much your benefits will be?

Medical records helping with compassionate allowance.

Do you have a severe medical condition?

Frequently Asked Questions About Fibromyalgia Disability Benefits

Is fibromyalgia a disability?

Fibromyalgia may qualify as a disabling impairment for SSDI and SSI benefits when it is established as a medically determinable impairment under SSR 12-2p and when your medical record documents that it prevents you from engaging in substantial gainful activity. A diagnosis alone is not sufficient. The SSA evaluates both what the medical evidence shows and what work, if any, you remain capable of performing.

Does fibromyalgia automatically qualify for disability?

No. The SSA’s five-step sequential evaluation applies in full to every fibromyalgia claim. At Step 1, the SSA determines whether you are engaging in substantial gainful activity. From there, the SSA must establish fibromyalgia as a medically determinable impairment under one of the two SSR 12-2p diagnostic paths, assess its severity, determine whether it medically equals a listing, and evaluate your RFC. Each step must be satisfied before benefits are approved.

What is SSR 12-2p?

SSR 12-2p—Social Security Ruling 12-2p, Titles II and XVI: Evaluation of Fibromyalgia—is the SSA policy ruling that governs how all fibromyalgia disability claims are evaluated. It establishes the two diagnostic paths for proving fibromyalgia as a medically determinable impairment, explains what documentation is required, and describes how the SSA considers fibromyalgia in the five-step sequential evaluation. Because fibromyalgia has no Blue Book listing, SSR 12-2p is the entire legal foundation of every fibromyalgia disability claim.

How hard is it to get disability for fibromyalgia?

Fibromyalgia claims face high initial denial rates because SSA reviewers frequently cite a lack of objective evidence: the same standard the Second Circuit rejected as legally erroneous in Green-Younger v. Barnhart. Many denials are reversed at the ALJ hearing level when a thorough longitudinal record is presented. The cases that succeed at the hearing level share consistent features: long-term physician documentation, a completed RFC assessment from the treating physician, records ruling out other disorders, and third-party statements about functional limitations.

This is New York Attorney Advertising. This website is designed for general information only.

The information presented in this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.

We may rely on co-counsel for some or all of the cases. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Is Fibromyalgia a Disability? Qualifying for SSDI Benefits

Fibromyalgia may qualify for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits, but the path to approval differs from most other disabling conditions. Fibromyalgia has no dedicated listing in the SSA’s Blue Book. Instead, it is evaluated under Social Security Ruling 12-2p, and approval depends on whether your medical record documents that the condition prevents you from engaging in any substantial gainful activity.

 

Some people with fibromyalgia manage their symptoms well enough to remain employed. Others live with widespread pain, severe fatigue, and cognitive difficulties that make sustained work impossible. For individuals who are unable to work, SSR 12-2p provides two diagnostic pathways for establishing fibromyalgia as a medically determinable impairment: the 1990 ACR tender-point criteria and the 2010 ACR symptom-based criteria. From there, the RFC evaluation is where most approved claims are won, and working with a Social Security disability lawyer improves your chances of approval at this stage.

 

Key Takeaways

  • Fibromyalgia has no dedicated Blue Book listing. It is evaluated entirely under Social Security Ruling 12-2p.
  • SSR 12-2p provides two diagnostic paths: the 1990 ACR tender-point criteria requiring 11 of 18 positive points, and the 2010 ACR symptom-based criteria requiring 6 or more documented symptoms.
  • Only a licensed physician can establish fibromyalgia as a medically determinable impairment. Nurse practitioners and physician assistants cannot make the diagnosis.
  • Most fibromyalgia claims are won through the RFC evaluation, not by medically equaling a listing.

What Is Fibromyalgia?

Fibromyalgia is a chronic pain condition characterized primarily by widespread musculoskeletal pain, fatigue, sleep disturbance, and cognitive difficulties that has persisted for at least three months. Unlike conditions such as arthritis or a herniated disc, fibromyalgia produces no visible tissue damage. There is no abnormality on imaging and no laboratory marker that confirms the diagnosis.

 

The condition frequently co-occurs with depression, anxiety, irritable bowel syndrome, migraines, and temporomandibular joint disorders. SSR 12-2p explicitly identifies co-occurring conditions as relevant factors in the disability evaluation, and they can compound the functional limitations fibromyalgia produces on its own.

 

Because no blood test or imaging study can conclusively confirm fibromyalgia, the SSA issued SSR 12-2p to establish exactly what evidence it requires and cannot require from claimants.

 

Symptoms of Fibromyalgia That Matter for a Social Security Disability Claim

A woman struggling with fibromyalgia symptoms sits on a couch as she leans over and places a hand on her head.Not all fibromyalgia symptoms carry equal weight in a disability evaluation. The SSA is interested in symptoms that prevent you from performing sustained work activity on a regular and continuing basis.

 

Symptoms that are most relevant to a disability claim include:

  • Widespread pain: Pain in all four quadrants of the body—both sides, above and below the waist—that persists for at least three months. The pain may fluctuate in intensity, which is precisely why the SSA requires longitudinal records rather than a snapshot from a single examination.
  • Fatigue and reduced stamina: Exhaustion that prevents you from maintaining a consistent schedule or completing a full workday. This is distinct from ordinary tiredness and must be documented in your treating physician’s notes.
  • Cognitive impairment (fibro fog): Difficulty concentrating, remembering instructions, and maintaining a consistent pace. This affects the ability to perform sedentary work that requires sustained mental focus.
  • Sleep disturbance: Waking unrefreshed despite adequate time in bed, which compounds both pain and fatigue and reduces functional capacity throughout the day.
  • Co-occurring conditions: Depression, anxiety, irritable bowel syndrome, and other conditions that frequently accompany fibromyalgia and further limit your ability to sustain work.

 

Because fibromyalgia symptoms fluctuate, a single medical appointment that shows relative improvement does not accurately represent your functional capacity. The SSA specifically accounts for this variability and requires longitudinal treatment records rather than a one-time evaluation. An experienced SSDI attorney can help ensure your longitudinal record is complete and presents your limitations accurately before you file your initial SSDI claim.

Bender and Bender Lawyers outside courthouse.

"*" indicates required fields

SSR 12-2p—The Social Security Ruling That Governs Fibromyalgia Claims

Fibromyalgia is not in the SSA’s Blue Book. Because no listing exists for it, fibromyalgia cannot satisfy a Blue Book listing at Step 3 of the SSDI benefits evaluation. Instead, the SSA evaluates all fibromyalgia disability claims under Social Security Ruling 12-2p.

 

SSR 12-2p establishes the framework for proving that fibromyalgia is a medically determinable impairment (MDI). Only a licensed physician can establish an MDI of fibromyalgia. A nurse practitioner or physician assistant cannot. The evidence must document that the physician reviewed your medical history and conducted a physical examination. A diagnosis statement alone is not sufficient under the ruling.

 

The ruling provides two diagnostic paths. Either can establish fibromyalgia as an MDI, and the SSA will use whichever path the available evidence best supports.

 

Path A — 1990 ACR Criteria

All three of the following must be present:

  1. Widespread pain. A history of pain in all four quadrants of the body—both sides, above and below the waist—and axial skeletal pain in the cervical spine, anterior chest, thoracic spine, or low back. This pain must have persisted for at least three months. It may fluctuate in intensity and may not always be present.
  2. At least 11 of 18 positive tender points on physical examination. The 18 tender-point sites are located at the occiput, low cervical spine, trapezius, supraspinatus, second rib, lateral epicondyle, gluteal, greater trochanter, and inner aspect of the knee. Testing is performed by digital palpation with approximately 9 pounds of pressure. A point is positive if you experience any pain when that pressure is applied. The positive points must be found bilaterally and both above and below the waist.
  3. Evidence that other disorders were ruled out. Other medical conditions can produce the same or similar symptoms as fibromyalgia, including rheumatologic disorders, myofascial pain syndrome, polymyalgia rheumatica, chronic Lyme disease, and cervical hyperextension disorders. Laboratory testing to rule these out may include a complete blood count, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, antinuclear antibody, thyroid function, and rheumatoid factor.

 

Path B — 2010 ACR Preliminary Diagnostic Criteria

All three of the following must be present:

  1. Widespread pain. Same as criterion 1 under Path A.
  2. Six or more fibromyalgia symptoms, signs, or co-occurring conditions. Repeated manifestations of at least six symptoms, especially fatigue, cognitive or memory problems, waking unrefreshed, depression, anxiety disorder, or irritable bowel syndrome. SSR 12-2p’s full list includes muscle pain, headache, abdominal pain, numbness or tingling, dizziness, insomnia, and others.
  3. Evidence that other disorders were ruled out. Same as criterion 3 under Path A.

 

Path B is available when tender-point testing results are not in your medical record. SSR 12-2p states explicitly that the SSA may use the 2010 criteria when the case record does not include tender-point testing results, or when the report does not describe the number and location of positive tender points.

How Many Fibromyalgia Claimants Receive SSDI Benefits: The RFC Pathway

Because no Blue Book listing exists for fibromyalgia, the sequential evaluation never reaches a finding of disability at Step 3 for most claimants. Fibromyalgia can only medically equal a listing; SSR 12-2p specifically gives inflammatory arthritis listing 14.09D as an example, or medically equal a listing in combination with another medically determinable impairment. Most fibromyalgia claims that succeed do so at Steps 4 and 5 through the Residual Functional Capacity (RFC) evaluation.

 

The RFC documents what you can still do physically and mentally despite your fibromyalgia. The SSA then uses your RFC alongside your age, education, and work history to determine whether any work exists in the national economy that you can realistically perform on a sustained, full-time basis.

 

For claimants over 50, the Medical-Vocational Guidelines, commonly called the Grid Rules, give significant weight to age when evaluating whether you can realistically transition to different work while managing fibromyalgia. A claimant over 50 who cannot return to past work and whose RFC is limited to sedentary activity faces a meaningfully different evaluation than a younger claimant with the same limitations.

 

A Social Security disability lawyer can ensure your RFC limitations are presented effectively in your claim and increase your chances of receiving benefits.

 

What Medical Evidence Strengthens a Fibromyalgia SSDI Claim

A fibromyalgia SSDI lawyer talks with a client about how they can qualify for social security disability benefits.Your claim should include:

  • Longitudinal physician treatment notes. Records from your treating physician spanning a significant period, documenting physical examination findings, tender-point testing or symptom assessments, treatment history, and your physician’s assessment of your functional abilities over time. The SSA places particular weight on longitudinal records precisely because fibromyalgia symptoms fluctuate.
  • Rheumatologist documentation. Evaluation and treatment records from a rheumatologist carry significant weight with SSA decision-makers.
  • Lab work ruling out other conditions. Records of testing that excluded other disorders satisfy the third criterion under both SSR 12-2p diagnostic paths and reinforce the legitimacy of the fibromyalgia diagnosis.
  • An RFC assessment from your treating physician. A form completed by your physician documenting your specific work-related limitations, such as how long you can sit, stand, and walk, how much you can lift, how often you would be off-task, and how many days per month you would likely miss work, carries significant weight at every stage of the evaluation.
  • Third-party statements. SSR 12-2p explicitly identifies statements from neighbors, friends, relatives, former employers, and others as relevant evidence for evaluating the severity and functional effects of fibromyalgia. These statements can document how your daily functioning compares to what medical records alone capture.

 

If you have any gaps in medical treatment, questions may arise about your symptom’s severity and may weaken a claim at both the initial and hearing levels.

 

How A Social Security Disability Lawyer Can Help

Fibromyalgia claims require building a longitudinal medical record that documents how your symptoms accumulate and fluctuate over time—a different challenge from conditions where imaging tells most of the story. Many initial claims are denied not because the applicant does not qualify, but because the medical record does not yet establish the severity and consistency of functional limitations the SSA requires. A Social Security disability lawyer can identify those gaps before you submit your initial applications and help you build the right record before you file.

 

If your application is denied, you have the right to appeal through reconsideration, a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge, the SSA Appeals Council, and federal court. Representation at the hearing stage can strengthen your claim.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fibromyalgia Disability Benefits

Is fibromyalgia a disability?

Fibromyalgia may qualify as a disabling impairment for SSDI and SSI benefits when it is established as a medically determinable impairment under SSR 12-2p and when your medical record documents that it prevents you from engaging in substantial gainful activity. A diagnosis alone is not sufficient. The SSA evaluates both what the medical evidence shows and what work, if any, you remain capable of performing.

Does fibromyalgia automatically qualify for disability?

No. The SSA’s five-step sequential evaluation applies in full to every fibromyalgia claim. At Step 1, the SSA determines whether you are engaging in substantial gainful activity. From there, the SSA must establish fibromyalgia as a medically determinable impairment under one of the two SSR 12-2p diagnostic paths, assess its severity, determine whether it medically equals a listing, and evaluate your RFC. Each step must be satisfied before benefits are approved.

What is SSR 12-2p?

SSR 12-2p—Social Security Ruling 12-2p, Titles II and XVI: Evaluation of Fibromyalgia—is the SSA policy ruling that governs how all fibromyalgia disability claims are evaluated. It establishes the two diagnostic paths for proving fibromyalgia as a medically determinable impairment, explains what documentation is required, and describes how the SSA considers fibromyalgia in the five-step sequential evaluation. Because fibromyalgia has no Blue Book listing, SSR 12-2p is the entire legal foundation of every fibromyalgia disability claim.

How hard is it to get disability for fibromyalgia?

Fibromyalgia claims face high initial denial rates because SSA reviewers frequently cite a lack of objective evidence: the same standard the Second Circuit rejected as legally erroneous in Green-Younger v. Barnhart. Many denials are reversed at the ALJ hearing level when a thorough longitudinal record is presented. The cases that succeed at the hearing level share consistent features: long-term physician documentation, a completed RFC assessment from the treating physician, records ruling out other disorders, and third-party statements about functional limitations.

Bender and Bender Lawyers outside courthouse.

"*" indicates required fields

A patient talks to their doctor about qualifying for social security disability benefits.
Paperwork needing a social security disability appeal.
Social Security Frequently Asked Questions Blocks

This is New York Attorney Advertising. This website is designed for general information only.

The information presented in this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.

We may rely on co-counsel for some or all of the cases. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.